Jesse the K (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
jesse_the_k) wrote in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
accessibility_fail2010-02-26 02:19 pm
jesse_the_k) wrote in accessibility_fail2010-02-26 02:19 pm
Entry tags:
The Reality of YouTube Autocaptions
(x-posted from my personal journal)
You may have seen Google/YouTube announce the magic of auto-captioning last November.
Gee whiz, they even had a deaf programmer write the blog entry. Things are good, right?
Watch this Bill Moyers interview with David Simon on YouTube. It's got captions. They're automagically generated with voice recognition. Compare the audio tracks and the caption track and be stunned at the high level of errors. Notice that White speakers' words are around 80% correct and Black speakers' words more like 30% correct.
Yes, it takes time to make good on technology's promise. In the meantime, disabled people put up with sub-standard services—and often at premium prices. When they're perfected, they'll be generally available.
These bad captions are particularly frustrating because the original sources were already captioned! Since the 1980s all network PBS (US public television) has been captioned; the same has been true for all HBO (paid US cable network) productions since 1995.
Arghhh.
You may have seen Google/YouTube announce the magic of auto-captioning last November.
Gee whiz, they even had a deaf programmer write the blog entry. Things are good, right?
Watch this Bill Moyers interview with David Simon on YouTube. It's got captions. They're automagically generated with voice recognition. Compare the audio tracks and the caption track and be stunned at the high level of errors. Notice that White speakers' words are around 80% correct and Black speakers' words more like 30% correct.
Yes, it takes time to make good on technology's promise. In the meantime, disabled people put up with sub-standard services—and often at premium prices. When they're perfected, they'll be generally available.
These bad captions are particularly frustrating because the original sources were already captioned! Since the 1980s all network PBS (US public television) has been captioned; the same has been true for all HBO (paid US cable network) productions since 1995.
Arghhh.